The Constitutional Convention considered at least three alternative options to the final Appointments Clause: (1) placing the power in the president alone, (2) in the legislature alone, (3) in the legislature with the presidents advice and consent.
On June 13, 1787, it was originally proposed that judges be appointed by the national Legislature, and that was rejected; Madison objected and made the alternative motion that appointments be made by the Senate, and that was at first approved. Madison specifically proposed that a supermajority be required for judicial appointments but this was rejected.
bttt