Posted on 05/11/2005 8:58:33 AM PDT by Pikamax
Italian TV to screen Dutch film despite Muslim protests over
John Hooper in Rome Wednesday May 11, 2005
Guardian
Italy's state broadcaster, RAI, will tomorrow defy protests from Muslims and reported threats to one of its executives when it becomes the first leading foreign TV network to show the controversial Dutch film Submission. The film's director, Theo van Gogh, was murdered last November. An alleged Muslim extremist has been charged with the killing.
The decision to screen substantial extracts from the film, which is fiercely critical of the treatment of women in Islam, followed a plea last week from Italian MPs from all leading parties. They said broadcasting the film would contribute "to artistic freedom and freedom of expression".
In a letter to President Carlo Azeglio Ciampi, the Islamic Council of Turin called for the broadcast to be cancelled. The letter, signed by two imams, said the content of the film was "detrimental to Islamic traditions and customs".
The imams warned that showing the film could create "new and drastic tensions that could induce the most fanatical to commit high-profile actions endangering public security". Copies of their letter were sent to, among others, the prime minister, Silvio Berlusconi, and the Vatican's secretary of state, Cardinal Angelo Sodano.
Critics of RAI's decision have argued that it is bowing to pressure from the anti-immi grant Northern League, which had earlier tried and failed to get the film shown at the European parliament.
Van Gogh's 12-minute film was written by a former Muslim who has become a member of the Dutch parliament representing an anti-immigration party. She was last reported to be in hiding under armed police guard.
Submission includes scenes of near-naked Muslim women in headscarves with verses from the Koran written on their bodies. According to someone who saw the film at a recent private viewing, it includes an interview with a woman who recounts a beating she endured for fleeing her home after being attacked and made pregnant by her uncle.
Some Dutch Muslim women who were victims of male violence reacted angrily when Submission was shown on television in the Netherlands last August, arguing that it cheapened their suffering. Van Gogh's murder two months later was followed by dozens of arson attacks on mosques and other Islamic targets, which in turn led to counter-attacks on churches.
The decision to screen the film in Italy was reported by the Northern League's daily, Padania, on Sunday. But the news was not carried in the national press, apparently for fear of stirring protests.
According to the Italian news agency Adnkronos, the RAI executive supervising the broadcast has already received anonymous threats.
A RAI official confirmed that it planned to air the film at 11pm tomorrow. Until now, only brief clips from Submission have been televised on national channels outside the Netherlands in news reports on Van Gogh's death. A northern Italian station has shown the film.
The Italian news agency Ansa yesterday reported that, following talks with the producers of Submission, RAI planned to broadcast a four to five-minute selection of excerpts.
Last month, the European parliament scrapped a screening of the film because of legal concerns and security fears.
Though Italian MPs of all parties have backed RAI's decision, the impetus for the screening has come largely from the Northern League, which has arranged showings at some of its premises.
Sounds like a very thinly-veiled threat.
Why would they want to show this movie? I thought that Islam is a religion of peace. </sarcasm>
"That's a nice tv station you have there. It'd be a shame if anything happened to it."
Good news. It's time for people to stop being intimidated.
"The letter, signed by two imams, said the content of the film was "detrimental to Islamic traditions and customs"."
Uh…that is exactly why it should be shown.
False ideologies cannot withstand criticism, which is exactly why there are protests from Muslims, and reported threats to one of its executives. Trying to silence critics of islam (like Theo Van Gogh) is something Mohammed did himself. Wonderful role model huh?
Religion of peace indeed.
What they should have said is that it will contribute to a better understanding of how oppressive, cruel, and backward the radical Muslim culture is. I hope it will awaken Italians to the dangers they're encouraging by allowing radicals to live in their country.
Could anyone tell me the name of the short film?
Bravo, RAI. I wonder if Submission will ever be shown here.
I cant' find the film on any of the RAI listings. Does anyone have an Idea of how we can find out if it really airs?
AHA! So they admit that abusing women is a custom!
The footage of the plane crashing into the second tower is all I needed to get the picture about Islam.
Translation: The film is spot on. We are savages.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.