Fair yes, after all they do consider European precedent in holdings where they have sworn to obey the Supreme Law of the Land, taht being the Constituion and laws enacted by Congress. What could be more fair than that?
Independent? Certainly, they have decided they are a law unto themsleves. Sodomy is enshrined somewhere in the Constituion but the right to life of full term babies is not nor is the right of parents to approve of medical intervention in their young children.
Can't get much more independent than that.
Can you believe this guy? I mean, maybe he's trying to soften the rhetoric given some unwise remarks by Cornyn and others, but come on. Fair and impartial?
Your (sarcastic) analysis is right on the money.