[AndyTheBear]

Actually, I stopped short of calling it an ad homonym fallacy directly. I asked you what other purpose you characterization served other then such a fallacy.

I'm not sure how you want the reader to interpret your "No" answer to this challenge. Being that literally it is an admission that such a fallacy was your only purpose.

[lugsoul]

You must practice a lot to be able to generalize that grossly.

You asked if my view applied to everyone who doesn't agree with me. I responded that it did not. That does not mean, however, that my characterization of what this forum has become is any less accurate, because there are persons who haven't succumbed to the mass hysteria.

Go back to logic class.