Posted on 03/24/2005 6:11:09 AM PST by slowhand520
Washington Prowler Dirty Democrat Pool By The Prowler Published 3/24/2005 12:08:04 AM
It's Rathergate all over again, and the same vigilant entities that brought about to the collapse of CBS News could now also cause heads to roll among Democratic Senate leadership staffers and further shame multiple news organizations that would appear to have fallen for another document hoax.
Very quietly, Senate Republican leadership aides to both Sen. Rick Santorum and Sen. Mitch McConnell, as well as the Senate Republican Policy Committee, have been using the Senate recess break to reconstruct the purported distribution of a document that media outlets, including ABC News, the New York Times and a number of regional newspapers, identified as Senate "GOP talking points" on the Terri Schiavo fight that unfolded over the weekend.
"There is a process here for documents like this that are passed around down on the Senate floor, which is where the media claimed that the 'talking points' were being distributed last Thursday," says a Republican policy committee staffer. "There was a lot of stuff going on Thursday, but a document like this one was not being distributed. As far as we know, the only documents being handed out related to votes on a series of amendments being pushed through before the recess. Schiavo wasn't part of that package."
The document, which was posted online by ABC News, as well as several Democratic-leaning websites, was unsigned, bore no Senate office letterhead, and was rife with errors, including the incorrect Senate bill number and the misspelling of Schiavo's name. For days, Republicans denied any knowledge of the document, and a number of Republican Senators claimed they had never seen it.
Beginning over the weekend, when doubts about the document first appeared on the blogosphere, the document's provenance began to unspool. Conservative blogs Powerline, In the Agora, and Fishkite all have been out front on the story. A number of blogs found language almost identical to the "talking points" on a post at the Traditional Values Coalition website. ABC News then posted the language of the purported document but not the actual document itself.
ABC News earlier this week was claiming to a number of online reporters that it never intended to create the impression that this was a Republican-generated document, only that it had been circulated among Republican Senators. The Washington Post claimed that it had confirmed the document's provenance, but could not reveal the source.
However, Republican leadership staffers now believe the document was generated out of the Democratic opposition research office set up recently by Sen. Harry Reid, and distributed to some Democratic Senate staffers claiming it was a GOP document, in the hope -- or more likely expectation -- that it would then be leaked by those Democrats to reporters. In fact, the New York Times stated that it was Democratic staffers who were distributing the "talking points" document.
"Democrats have tried to pin this document on Santorum's staff, on [Sen. Bill] Frist's staff, on [Sen. Sam] Brownback's staff," says a Senate leadership staffer. "Watching the investigation underway on line has energized us enough up here to want to at least confirm that we weren't the source, and everything we have found would confirm that Republicans didn't generate this memo. This is just amateurish, and perhaps Democratic staffers think we put out work product like this, but it's laughable."
The staffer added that while just about any House or Senate staffer with an email account could readily distribute a document, it was a huge stretch to believe that such a document would end up being widely distributed by or even to Senators in the cloakroom or in the well of the Senate. "This has all the telltale signs of a political dirty trick," says the staffer.
Other Republican staffers blame not only Democrats but also the mainstream media which once again put out a story to embarrass Republicans before checking all the facts first.
Republicans staffers looking into the "talking points" case believe that at least some of the language used for the original Traditional Values Coalition may have come from documents pulled together by the staff of Sen. Mel Martinez, who has been out front on the Schiavo case, and pressed hard for federal action to save her life. But there is no evidence that the talking points were a Martinez staff product.
I told JimRob yesterday that they had cobbled this memo together in MS Word, again.
These people keep going back to the same poisoned well.
MSM still busy trying to prove that Rather's documents were authentic.
It won't be another Rathergate. Although the MSM avoids the word "forgery" like the plague, Rathergate was FORGERY. This is merely a political dirty trick, like a million other dirty tricks the Democrats have played.
De-ja-vu ... the eager liberal weenies in the MSM are only too eager to belly up to the 'Rat trough of misinformation, gobble it up ... and regurgitate in the print and network media.
Despicable behavior - and these people are responsible for governing this country?
Chirac is beginning to look like a nice guy.
sp
Isn't it time for the demonrats to start screaming about the "timing" or the Pubbies leaking internal demon memos to take the heat off what they did.
Northern Alliance bloggers strike again!
THis exact same thing happened on the West Wing. I can't remember the exact issue, but a Republican Senator was advocating for something and a WH staffer found her exact talking points on a religious-activist group website. Did some DUmmie get the idea from the show?
This wouldn't be the only case of the Dems following the lead of the West Wing. Remember when (s)Kerry told that union guy that they had to "...get thes f'ing guys out..." and the cameras picked it up? He claimed he didn't know the cameras were on. "President BArtlett" did the same thing on the WW when he called Governor Richie (Pres. Bush type character portrayed by Brolin) supid.
so what was in this fake memo that made us look bad?
It doesn't matter, ABC stands by the letter because although fabricated, they believe if the GOP circulated a letter it would have similar content.
Wait, I thought the West Wing was real. You mean I'm not really president?
Martin
Who We Are (a dipsh*t attack conservative media group)
Media Matters for America is a Web-based, not-for-profit, 501(c)(3) progressive research and information center dedicated to comprehensively monitoring, analyzing, and correcting conservative misinformation in the U.S. media.
Launched in May 2004, Media Matters for America put in place, for the first time, the means to systematically monitor a cross section of print, broadcast, cable, radio, and Internet media outlets for conservative misinformation -- news or commentary that is not accurate, reliable, or credible and that forwards the conservative agenda -- every day, in real time.
Using the website www.mediamatters.org as the principal vehicle for disseminating research and information, Media Matters posts rapid-response items as well as longer research and analytic reports documenting conservative misinformation throughout the media. Additionally, Media Matters works daily to notify activists, journalists, pundits, and the general public about instances of misinformation, providing them with the resources to rebut false claims and to take direct action against offending media institutions.
Staff and Advisers
David S. Bennahum is an author, journalist, and leading new media thinker. He was one of the founding writers with Wired magazine and is a frequent television and radio commentator on issues relating to technology and society. His writing has appeared in Slate, The Economist, New York magazine, and The New York Times; his next book, titled Fair Play (Gotham Books), traces the evolution of the concept of team sports in modern society. Bennahum is a Senior Fellow at Media Matters for America and assists in guiding online communications and technology strategy.
Duncan B. Black has held teaching and research positions at the London School of Economics; the Université catholique de Louvain; the University of California, Irvine; and, recently, Bryn Mawr College. Black holds a PhD in economics from Brown University and is a Senior Fellow at Media Matters for America.
David Brock is the author of four political books, including The Republican Noise Machine: Right-Wing Media and How It Corrupts Democracy. His preceding book, Blinded by the Right: The Conscience of an Ex-Conservative, was a 2002 New York Times best-selling political memoir in which he chronicled his years as a conservative media insider. Brock serves on the advisory board of Democracy Radio Inc. and is the recipient of the New Democrat Network's first award for political entrepreneurship. He is the President and CEO of Media Matters for America.
Nicole Casta has worked in government relations for the National Organization for Women (NOW) and The National Partnership for Women and Families, monitoring and analyzing a range of policy issues including: civil rights, educational equity, reproductive rights, women's health, and workplace fairness. Casta is a graduate of Wellesley College and is a member of the Research Department at Media Matters for America.
Jeremy Cluchey has conducted education policy research for the Albert Shanker Institute and has worked on federal workforce issues as a fellow with the Partnership for Public Service. Originally from Maine, he studied English and government at Wesleyan University and spent a semester in India, Nepal, and Tibet studying regional politics and history. Cluchey is a member of the Research Department at Media Matters for America.
Jamison Foser has extensive experience in progressive research, communications, and strategy, having worked for nearly a decade in national politics. Most recently he served as Research Director at the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC) for the 2002 cycle. Foser is a Senior Adviser at Media Matters for America.
David Grossman has a broad range of experience in grassroots campaigning and progressive activism through his work in congressional offices, trade associations, and nonprofit organizations. Grossman holds a bachelor's degree from American University and is a member of the External Affairs Department at Media Matters for America.
Adam Hundt has co-directed a Democratic National Committee grassroots fund-raising office in California and has worked as an Oregon field organizer for MoveOn PAC's "2004 Leave No Voter Behind" get-out-the-vote campaign. Hundt is a graduate of Brown University and is an intern in the Research Department at Media Matters for America.
Paul Hyland has been working as a web developer, information architect, and online producer for over ten years. He most recently worked on web site redesigns for the National Association of Securities Dealers and the District of Columbia Government; he also managed production and online communities for the music and education channels at America Online. He serves on the board of directors of Computer Professionals for Social Responsibility, and has been speaking and writing about the social impacts of computing technology and the Internet for the past twenty years. Hyland is the Director of Technology at Media Matters for America.
Terry Krepel has worked for newspapers for more than 17 years as a reporter, designer, and editor. He is the creator and editor of ConWebWatch, which monitors conservative news websites. Krepel holds a master's degree in multimedia journalism from Arkansas Tech University and is a Web Editor at Media Matters for America.
Marcia Kuntz most recently ran the Alliance for Justice's Judicial Selection Project. Previously, she served as minority counsel for the housing subcommittee of the House Committee on Banking and Financial Services and as legislative counsel to Representative Barney Frank (D-MA). A graduate of Princeton University and the University of Chicago Law School, Kuntz is the Editorial Director at Media Matters for America.
Simon Maloy most recently worked for Kaplan Higher Education Online in New York as an editorial intern. He has been published in The Raw Story, a progressive news website. Maloy holds a bachelor's degree in history from Williams College and is a member of the Research Department at Media Matters for America.
Matt McLaughlin has worked as a reporter and editor for newspapers since 1989, covering government, courts, education, and technology, among other issues. He holds a bachelor's degree in English and mass communications from Towson University and is a Senior Editor at Media Matters for America.
Melissa Salmanowitz has developed both editorial and political press experience through internships at U.S. News & World Report and the U.S. House of Representatives. Salmanowitz is a graduate of the University of Massachusetts and is a member of the Communications Department at Media Matters for America.
Raphael Schweber-Koren previously worked as a researcher for the Thunder Road Group, following internships at National Public Radio and the AFL-CIO. Schweber-Koren holds a bachelor's degree in computer science from Johns Hopkins University and is a member of the Research Department at Media Matters for America.
Andrew Seifter has experience organizing, advocating, and fundraising for several progressive not-for-profit groups, including the Sierra Club, Greenpeace, and the State PIRGs. He also served as a research assistant for a Member of the British Parliament. Seifter holds a bachelor of arts from the University of Michigan and a master of science from the London School of Economics. Seifter is a member of the Research Department at Media Matters for America.
Brian Szymanski is a technologist and independent media activist. He has been actively involved in computer recycling, independent radio, Free software, and antiwar and human rights activism. Szymanski attended Cornell University and is a member of the Technology and Online Community Department at Media Matters for America.
Gabriel Wildau most recently worked as a policy analyst for General (Ret.) Wesley K. Clark's presidential campaign. Wildau also has interned at The American Prospect. He graduated magna cum laude from Brown University and is a member of the Research Department at Media Matters for America.
Oliver Willis has worked as a Web developer and information architect on several media-related Web projects. He also boasts extensive experience in political blogging and authors his own site, which has been profiled in The Boston Globe and Baseline magazine, and on PBS. Willis attended Florida Atlantic University and is a member of the Technology and Online Community Department at Media Matters for America.
The context is all wrong. There aren't enough major elements (presidential election etc.) to provide the necessary pressure to produce more than a little popping sound.
Dan Rather was playing with a pressure cooker and this is nothing more than an egg poacher.
MSM's Non-story of the week.
Two down, one to go. What've we got on NBC?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.