WHY just those TWO choices, how about the 3rd one?
She moves back home with the Schindlers, enjoys sunshine, music, kittens, warm baths, gets back a little (or lot) of her functioning, and lives happily for as long as Michael predicted on the witness stand - 60 more years!
I like your third choice the best.
But from my understanding the legal proceedings have nothing to do with her gaurdianship and are only concerned with whether or not feeding and hydration is concidered artificial life support.
Is my understanding correct?
It does seem that the right thing to do is to give her parents gaurdianship unless either he truly believe she would rather be dead or he is afraid that whe will regain enough consciousness and say that her condition is a result of a failed murder attempt.