She did not find his human side. She found his gullible side. Heck, I can trick my cat into coming by using the "dinner" tone of voice. He's not human.
She feels "sorry for him". That goes too far.
ooh that's funny!!! and so true!!LOL
If you are comparing your cat to that quadruple murderer, you owe your cat an apology, a tummy rub and a can of "the good stuff".
She may not have 'tricked' him but genuinely was living her faith. I've found that a Christian response often works better than my former non-Christian self would have credited.