To: BigEdLB
In the sense of 'evil', No. Along for the ride, yes. Rehnquist came on the Court just before I started law school. A great jurist? Yes. A great Chief Justice, I think, regrettably, no. Rehnquist has failed to put his imprimatur on the Court he has led for so long, and the fact you have so many 5-4, 6-3 decisions, with his side losing too many is proof of that.
Scalia is brilliant, and also because he's so acerbic, and does not suffer fools gladly, i.e many of his fellow justices, is marginalized. Scalia will always write brilliant, well reasoned opinions. He will also write, almost invariably, minority opinions. Justice Thomas is a solid justice with more people skills than Scalia. Unfortunately, he doesn't seem to be able to dominate or bring around the idiot six.
240 posted on
03/02/2005 4:25:05 PM PST by
PzLdr
(Liberals are like slugs-they leave a trail of slime wherever they go.)
To: PzLdr
Don't goive up hope, with yesterday's debachle, the slinky six (5-1/2) may have bitten off more than they can chew.
I would be willing to bet many a senator's office has been inundated with phone calls supporting a "Nuclear" option. We may even see one of the RINOs change to yes on the rule change because of the Soverignty issue...
Listen to Laura Ingraham tomorrow - She had a lot of well placed anger today about this, and made one feel that one was not alone...
242 posted on
03/02/2005 4:36:04 PM PST by
BigEdLB
(BigEd)
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson