Posted on 02/24/2005 10:11:16 AM PST by West Coast Conservative
An MP who was a founder member of Labour Against the War has quit the group, saying that after last month’s elections in Iraq he now believed Allied troops should remain in the country, it emerged today.
Harry Barnes’ defection will be welcomed by the Labour leadership, which fears that many of the party’s traditional supporters will stay at home in the forthcoming General Election because of anger over Iraq.
The North-East Derbyshire MP, who is stepping down at the election, accused his former colleagues in the anti-war movement of retailing "simple-minded" claims about the extent of civilian casualties in Iraq since the war.
He told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme: "I joined Labour Against the War from the start and was on the original platform next to Tony Benn and fully supported action to stop the war, but things have moved and changed."
He could no longer support the anti-war camp’s demands for withdrawal of troops of the US-led coalition, which he said should be a decision for the Iraqi people.
"The Iraqi people now have an avenue for expressing their opinion through their Parliament and the Government that has been established," he said. "The coalition should be there a little longer to hold the ring."
Mr Barnes accused the anti-war movement of offering a "one-sided" view of life in Iraq, endlessly repeating the 100,000 casualty estimate produced in an analysis of deaths caused by the conflict, published in the academic journal The Lancet.
"That analysis said it could be anything between 2,000 and 198,000," he said. "Some things are just over-the-top and simple-minded."
Prominent anti-war campaigner and Labour MP Alice Mahon said Mr Barnes appeared to have accepted a misleadingly rosy view of the January 30 elections.
There were "huge question marks" over the conduct of the elections, including claims that ballot boxes for 400,000 people were not supplied, she said.
"Harry is an old friend and I am very sorry he has gone, but I think he has been misled," she told Today. "This remains an illegal invasion and an illegal occupation."
My Dad always said: "A fool never changes his mind, a wise man does often." Of course he would tell me this just after he changed his mind.
So who is this guy? Is he a H. Clinton that reverses himself because he can see Iraq is headed toward success and wishes credit and advancement in political life.
Or is this conversion sincere?
The wheels are coming off of the lefty movement
the 100,000 death estimate was based on a verifiable sample of 63.
I figured that those images of Iraqis risking death to line up and vote had to be making at least some Libs reexamine their beliefs. Apparently so.
ping
It sounds like this fellow has an open mind, is intellectually honest, is willing to change his mind, and is sincerely concerned about the people of Iraq. How refreshing. He should be applauded.
Bottom Line: They all believed that democracy wasn't possible in the Middle East.
Bush is a step ahead once again.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.