"You're right. But the size of our tent is irrelevant. She's still wrong."
I agree that she's wrong on this one. I just refuse to drink the kool-aide. The attacks on Noonan at FR are motivated by spite, envy, ignorance, and jealousy.
i think peggy can take the criticism, despite not liking it, and doesn't need you pegging her critics as spiteful, ignorant and jealous of her. most of us are just honestly perplexed as to how she could go from praising it immediately after it's delivery, to rather meanspirited sounding criticism the next day, which is continuing.
She has been wrong on several columns. She is positioning herself in the Christie Todd Whitman section of the tent. That observation is not based on envy or spite. It is an objective point of view. You're darling Peggy is crossing over. Get over it.
Hardly. I'm not jealous, envious, ignorant to the fact, or in spite of the fact she heaped praise on President Bush's speech on TV the night before the first column came out. She's done this to herself.
I'm neither envious or jealous of her present conundrum of having to clarify her previous column. Her greatest achievement at the outset of this column was the objective she achieved in the first place, which was that she continued to muddy up the waters of confusion.
You think this is bad....You should see the attacks on her from the left.
Are you Peggy Noonan, or related to her? To claim that these discussions are mtivated by envy and jealousy is ridiculous. Anyone can see that Peggy has been abducted by Pod people and we want her back.