You must weigh each piece of evidence as to credibility.
You discard some. You take others under advisement and you find others to be credible.
Even if evidence is false, it is still evidence.
I think, after a long walk, you're making my point. The evidence some people seek can be just as easily false as true. No human has any basis to judge the relative reliability of evidence for G-d's existence, One has either faith or one wants proof. Take your pick.