[highlandbreeze]

But he has to give it back to her. He can refuse to fill the script, but he cannot refuse her the right to go elsewhere to have it filled. These are birth control pills.

[Protagoras]

But he has to give it back to her. He can refuse to fill the script, but he cannot refuse her the right to go elsewhere to have it filled.

Precisely. But the part about him refusing to fill it is well within his rights.