I think I'm way too paranoid, too. And I wish I never said the "H" word because it looks like it's caught fire now that we've actually seen (parts of) the tape on FNC.
I'd hate for this to not be taken seriously just because the video doesn't look like we think it's supposed to. Who are we to know what the heck a terrorism tape is SUPPOSED to look like? Especially when the jihadi speaks English? As smogger said on the other thread, if ISI (Pakistani spy agency) and Al Jazeera and yes, even terrorism expert Evan Kohlmann say it's legit - well, they know more than me.
Sorry, forgot to ping you to #543 seeing I mentioned you and all.
If it's the person they think it is...that kid (Andy?) who is on the FBI list, he could come forward and say anything but very few people would believe him.
Let's not over-worry this thing. Although it's hard not to try and figure out why ABC was holding this :-)