Posted on 10/09/2004 9:37:00 AM PDT by Jalapeno
Oct. 9, 2004, 10:29AM
BEAUMONT -- A Southeast Texas businessman is upset that his son's English class watched Michael Moore's scathing documentary on President Bush and his handling of events after the terrorist attacks. ADVERTISEMENT
Michael Kurth, a veteran, said he was opposed to the film "Fahrenheit 9/11" based on its R rating and political partisanship. His son Matthew, 17, said that he put his head on his desk and tried to sleep through it.
"It bothered me," he said.
Moore's condemnation of Bush's actions regarding the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks on the World Trade Center and Pentagon became the first documentary to top the $100 million mark domestically. In the film, Moore examines the Bush administration's alleged financial ties to Saudi Arabia and the bin Laden family.
"It is spun to a very liberal viewpoint," the businessman said. "It is absolutely wrong for teachers to take a political position with some of these kids at legal voting age."
Michael Ryals, principal of Pathways Learning Center, said that he previewed part of the film before he allowed the teacher to show it in class Friday.
"I didn't hear anything that was offensive to me," he told the Beaumont Enterprise in today's editions, adding that he did not know of the R rating.
Ryals said one student told him of another movie that takes an opposing view and he urged the student to bring it Monday for review to see if it could be shown.
Pathways is an alternative school for students moved from their home campuses for disciplinary reasons. Kurth said his son is at the school for 40 days after having too many tardies.
Beaumont Independent School District spokeswoman Jolene Ortego said she spoke to Kurth and assured him the matter would be addressed by Monday morning.
School board trustee John Williams said R-rated films should not be shown without parental consent.
Kurth, 39, said he watched it to see all sides and decided he did not want his family to see it, then was "livid" to hear that his son's class was viewing it weeks before the general election.
Earlier this summer, thousands of people watched the documentary in Crawford, Bush's adopted hometown, where Moore's staff had made arrangements to send a copy after learning that no theaters in the Waco area had been showing the film. A Waco theater subsequently agreed to screen the film.
your tax dollars at work ping
Yeah, but did they get some rotten tomatoes to throw?
Didn't know about the R rating? As if the idiot principal couldn't read the rating on the box.
This crap has to stop. It would never fly the other way around. Somebody's ass should get busted over this bs.
This is southeast Texas where there is the LAST bastion of heavy union influence and corruption. I am not surprised that BISD has allowed it. This is the home of 2 of the 5 biggest Texas personal injury law firms that did the Texas tobacco litigation. Nuf said.
Maybe for extra credit, the teacher can send the kids to key cars with Bush/Cheney bumper stickers, or tear up signs on people's lawns.
The only possible justification I can think of for watching F911 in class is to study and dissect it as a propaganda film.
The movie has no historical value, and no artistic value. It's viciously partisan. So how can you possibly justify it as part of anyone's "education"?
Even if it were to be used to analyze propaganda techniques, I can think of better film examples to use. Leni Riefenstahl's "Triumph of the Will," for instance, which is far superior both as propaganda and as art.
Or how about "Birth of a Nation," perhaps the all-time great propaganda film and likewise generally recognized as a great artistic accomplishment and a major milestone in the history of film making.
All fine and good, she said, but we had to stay and watch. So we did, more or less. After the lights came up, she asked for opinions. My friend Jeff answered "good story, but lame acting", to which she said "Actually, I agree; just remember that the next time Hollywood makes a movie out of your favorite book!"...
You can show Moore propaganda to the kids in your class but if you say the Pledge its a crime against humanity...
Exactly what the problem is in America.
we watched bowling for columbine as half the semester in my english comp 1 class last semester... it is in college, but still made me mad and sick... grrrrrrrrrrr.... :-D
You can show Moore propaganda to the kids in your class but if you say the Pledge its a crime against humanity...
Exactly what the problem is in America.
My son's science teacher tried to show "Bowling for Columbine" last year in class. Luckily, she sent home permission slips to make the parents sign. Nobody would sign. The film was not shown.
If this happened in my kids school I wouldn't stop raising cain until the teacher had been run out of the school.
WHAT?!!!!!!
This is our educational system? An alternative school where kids go because of problems they've had in school need to be taught the reading, writing and math or basic history and geography that they have missed in regular classes, not having films for the "nuances" of propaganda.
How could any teacher show any film when these kids can't read or count change back at McDonalds?
Disgusting waste of our tax dollars to pay for a teacher who's too lazy to teach.
I think a lawsuit that makes a Kerry-Edwards-Jackson 'shakedown' look like a coin tossed into a Salvation Army kettle, is in order.
Reason #88 I'm not a Democrat.
What a disgraceful, low-class thing to do. Pigs.
It is illegal to show a copyrighted Video to a class, they are for single family viewing only. No public showings allowed.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.