1) Giuliani - A - Hit all the right notes, inspiration, very convincing.
2) McCain - B - Fairly standard fare, some good lines, bonus points for the zing at Michael Moore.
3) Arnold - C+ - Great delivery, Lots of recycled lines from his recall speeches, too many cliques and movie lines (tough guy movie quotes are getting stale at this point, Arnold), appropriate subject matter to appeal to all Republicans (wish he would impliment his own "fiscally conservative" beliefs)
FGS!
Arnold's speech was a grand slam.
I agree with you on Guiliani and McCain, but I think Arnold deserves higher than a C. Maybe an A-. His going through the long list saying "then that makes you a Republican" was great. But that's just my opinion. He was speaking to the choir with me, so I don't know how independents took it.