Besides --- how can someone prove it was themselves and not someone else who was fraudulently using a stolen social security number? What happens when 10 illegals claim to have used the same number for the same 6 quarters? Do all 10 get full benefits?
"Do all 10 get full benefits?"
Yes, it's likely. Not long ago, we read about all the fraudulent documents, SS cards etc. these people get from the coyotes bringing them in. A couple years ago, I was at the SS office. There were 4 young, strong looking "hispanics" in line in front of me. They had to get them an interpreter. They were there to change their address for their checks.
"Besides --- how can someone prove it was themselves and not someone else who was fraudulently using a stolen social security number? What happens when 10 illegals claim to have used the same number for the same 6 quarters? Do all 10 get full benefits?"
The person who was fraudently working has the W2 in hand and submits it to the SSA office.
If it's stolen - the credits should go to the legitimate card holder. If the card is rented, the holder should price it into his rent:
Card without benefits: $100 a year
card with benefits: $150 a year
our something like that (actual prices may vary)
the government should stay out of it, and leave it up to the renter to collect based on the agreement he made