[StoneColdGOP]

The whole history of Middle-earth is incredible, I'd love to see "The Silmarillion" as a film too.

[HairOfTheDog]

I'd love to see "The Silmarillion" as a film too.

Silmarillion is a bunch of disconnected stories, it would be like filming the Old Testament. Any of the individual chapters and stories could be adapted to film and be better.

[Foxfire4]

If you're a Silmarillion fan, drop in here. I have inflicted far too many quotes from this thing on my poor undeserving husband.

And I'd love to see some Silmarillion-based movies...Earandil and Elwing for story purposes, and the Akallabeth for special effects.

-Foxfire4, trailing off in geeky bliss