Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

The Pastiche of a Presidency, Imitating a Life, in 957 Pages (NYT book review, not wholly positive)
The New York Times ^ | June 20, 2004 | MICHIKO KAKUTANI

Posted on 06/19/2004 11:43:23 AM PDT by AM2000

As his celebrated 1993 speech in Memphis to the Church of God in Christ demonstrated, former President Bill Clinton is capable of soaring eloquence and visionary thinking. But as those who heard his deadening speech nominating Michael Dukakis at the 1988 Democratic National Convention in Atlanta well know, he is also capable of numbing, self-conscious garrulity.

Unfortunately for the reader, Mr. Clinton's much awaited new autobiography "My Life" more closely resembles the Atlanta speech, which was so long-winded and tedious that the crowd cheered when he finally reached the words "In closing . . ."

The book, which weighs in at more than 950 pages, is sloppy, self-indulgent and often eye-crossingly dull — the sound of one man prattling away, not for the reader, but for himself and some distant recording angel of history.

In many ways, the book is a mirror of Mr. Clinton's presidency: lack of discipline leading to squandered opportunities; high expectations, undermined by self-indulgence and scattered concentration. This memoir underscores many strengths of Mr. Clinton's eight years in the White House and his understanding that he was governing during a transitional and highly polarized period. But the very lack of focus and order that mars these pages also prevented him from summoning his energies in a sustained manner to bring his insights about the growing terror threat and an Israeli-Palestinian settlement to fruition.

Certainly it's easy enough to understand the huge advance sales for the book. Mr. Clinton would seem to have all the gifts for writing a gripping memoir: gifts of language, erudition and charm, combined with a policy wonk's perception of a complex world at a hinge moment in time, teetering on the pivot between Cold War assumptions and a new era of global interdependence. Add to that his improbable life story — a harrowing roller-coaster ride of precocious achievements, self-inflicted slip-ups and even more startling comebacks — and you have all the ingredients for a compelling book.

But while Dan Rather, who interviewed Mr. Clinton for "60 Minutes," has already compared the book to the memoirs of Ulysses S. Grant, arguably the most richly satisfying autobiography by an American president, "My Life" has little of that classic's unsparing candor or historical perspective. Instead, it devolves into a hodgepodge of jottings: part policy primer, part 12-step confessional, part stump speech and part presidential archive, all, it seems, hurriedly written and even more hurriedly edited.

In fact, "My Life" reads like a messy pastiche of everything that Mr. Clinton ever remembered and wanted to set down in print; he even describes the time he got up at 4 a.m. to watch the inaugural ceremonies for Nigeria's new president on TV. There are endless litanies of meals eaten, speeches delivered, voters greeted and turkeys pardoned. There are some fascinating sections about Mr. Clinton's efforts to negotiate a Middle East peace agreement (at one point, he suggests that Yasir Arafat seemed confused, not fully in command of the facts and possibly no longer at the top of his game), but there are also tedious descriptions of long-ago political debates in Arkansas over utility regulation and car license fees . There are some revealing complaints about missteps at the FBI under Louis Freeh's watch , but there are also dozens of pointless digressions about matters like zombies in Haiti and ruins in Pompeii.

Mr. Clinton confesses that his affair with Monica Lewinsky was "immoral and foolish," but he spends far more space excoriating his nemesis, independent counsel Kenneth W. Starr, and the press. He writes at length about his awareness that terrorism was a growing threat, but does not grapple with the unintended consequences of his administration's decisions to pressure Sudan to expel Osama bin Laden in 1996 (driving sent the al Qaeda leader to Afghanistan, where he was harder to track) or to launch cruise missile attacks against targets in Sudan and Afghanistan in retaliation for the embassy bombings in 1998 (an act that some terrorism experts believe fueled terrorists' conviction that the United States was an ineffectual giant that relied on low-risk high technology).

Part of the problem, of course, is that Mr. Clinton is concerned, here, with cementing — or establishing — his legacy, while at the same time boosting (or at least not undermining) the political career of his wife, Hillary Rodham Clinton. He does a persuasive job of explicating his more successful initiatives like welfare reform and deficit reduction, but the failure of his health care initiative, overseen by Mrs. Clinton, is quickly glossed over, as is the subsequent focus of his administration on such small-bore initiatives as school uniforms and teenage smoking.

Mr. Clinton takes more responsibility in these pages for his affair with Ms. Lewinsky, his lies about that affair and the damage those actions inflicted on his family and his presidency than he has in the past. But he still spends a lot of time — like his wife did in her book — assailing right-wing enemies for his woes over Whitewater, the Paula Jones case and impeachment. In the end, he says, what brought him and his wife back together was weekly counseling sessions and their shared determination "to fight off the right-wing coup." He sheds little new light on his relationship with Mrs. Clinton, simply noting that he always admired her mix of idealism and practicality, and that she initially hesitated over his marriage proposal, knowing that "being married to me would be a high-wire operation in more ways than one." In another passage, Mr. Clinton tries to characterize his impeachment fight as "my last great showdown with the forces I had opposed all of my life" - with those who had defended segregation in the South, opposed the women's and gay rights movements, and who believed government should be run for the benefit of special interests. He adds that he was glad that he had had "the good fortune to stand against this latest incarnation of the forces of reaction and division."

In comparison to these self-serving, often turgid attempts to defend his reputation, Mr. Clinton's account of his youth in Arkansas possesses a pleasing emotional directness. His portraits of life in the raffish Hot Springs and the more sedate Hope (towns that would became the polestars of his Janus-faced personality, what political guru Dick Morris once called "Saturday Night Bill" and "Sunday Morning Clinton") may lack the raw energy of his mother Virginia Kelley's reminiscences, set down in her 1994 book "Leading With My Heart," but he does provide the reader with some telling snapshots of his awkward childhood: a fat, self-conscious boy dressed in a new Easter outfit every year — including, one year, pink and black Hush Puppies and a matching pink suede belt; breaking his leg trying to jump rope wearing cowboy boots; devouring books about Geronimo and Crazy Horse at the local library.

Looking back on those days of living with a violent, abusive stepfather, Mr. Clinton writes like someone familiar with therapeutic tropes. He writes that seeing his stepfather angry and drunk, he came to associate anger with being out of control, and determined to keep his own anger locked away. He writes about experiencing a "major spiritual crisis" at the age of 13, when he found it difficult to sustain a belief in God in the face of his family's difficulties. And he writes about the coping mechanisms he developed — including learning to live "parallel lives" where he walled off his anger and grief to get on with his daily life.

Many events recounted in this book have been chronicled before —- not just by the dozens of reporters and biographers who have swarmed over Mr. Clinton's life, but by people close to the former president, including his wife, his mother, his brother Roger, Ms. Lewinsky, and former members of his administration like George Stephanopoulos and Robert Reich. For the most part, the self-portrait that emerges from this book is not all that different a Bill Clinton from the one the public has already come to know: tireless, driven, boyish, self-absorbed and optimistic, someone riven by contradictions but adept at compartmentalizing different parts of his life.

Mr. Clinton once remarked that he saw character as "a journey, not a destination," and at the end of this book, he cites "becoming a good person" as one of his life goals. Still, the seeds of his adult self can be glimpsed in an autobiographical essay he wrote in high school: "I am a living paradox — deeply religious, yet not as convinced of my exact beliefs as I ought to be; wanting responsibility yet shirking it; loving the truth but often times giving way to falsity." It is only because Mr. Clinton was president of the United States that these excavations of self — a staple of celebrity and noncelebrity memoirs these days — are considered newsworthy.

The nation's first baby-boomer president always seemed like an avatar of his generation, defined by the struggles of the 60's and Vietnam, comfortable in the use of touchy-feely language, and intent on demystifying his job. And yet the former president's account of his life, read in this post-9/11 day, feels strangely like an artifact from a distant, more innocent era.

Lies about sex and real estate, partisan rancor over "character issues" (not over weapons of mass destruction or pre-emptive war), psychobabble mea culpas, and tabloid wrangles over stained dresses all seem like pressing matters from another galaxy, far, far away.


TOPICS: Editorial; Front Page News; News/Current Events; US: Arkansas
KEYWORDS: book; bookreview; clinton; impeachedx42; kakutani; michiko; michikokakutani; mylife
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 41-6061-8081-100 ... 121-132 next last
To: AM2000

A little off topic: Jay Leno had a funny one the other night. Said, "Did you hear Bill Clinton is going to talk about his infidelities on 60 minutes this Sunday. 60 Minutes? Dontchya think he should be on 48 Hours instead????"


61 posted on 06/19/2004 2:44:40 PM PDT by Hildy ( If you don't stand up for what's RIGHT, you'll settle for what's LEFT.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: AM2000
To: MICHIKO KAKUTANI
From: New York Times Editorial Board
Re: Clean out your desk on Mon. 6/20
62 posted on 06/19/2004 2:46:55 PM PDT by jern
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Hildy

950 pages of words = cheap doorstop when it goes on the remainder shelf.


63 posted on 06/19/2004 2:48:06 PM PDT by Carolinamom
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 61 | View Replies]

To: itsahoot

Yeah! You're right, it's a relief to poke fun, but Hillary isn't going away. I don't know how it is possible to educate the masses on discernment when the media is so leftist yet denies it every step. If only our educational system really taught people to pick things apart and think about things.


64 posted on 06/19/2004 2:53:59 PM PDT by thinkingman129 (questioning clears the way to understanding.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 60 | View Replies]

To: Libertina

LOL, I can only imagine that Gail Collins, Krugman, Maureen Dowd are having a cow over this review about now.


65 posted on 06/19/2004 3:14:58 PM PDT by finnman69 (hOcum puella incedit minore medio corpore sub quo manifestus globus, inflammare animos)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: TXnMA

Or Rush, this could be Rush's lead item Monday.


66 posted on 06/19/2004 3:17:41 PM PDT by finnman69 (hOcum puella incedit minore medio corpore sub quo manifestus globus, inflammare animos)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 20 | View Replies]

To: finnman69
Since the admin moderator pulled my thread I'll comment here.



'Sloppy, self-indulgent and often eye-crossingly dull... the sound of one man prattling away, not for the reader, but for himself and some distant recording angel of history'...


NYT BRUTAL BOOK REVIEW FOR BUBBA

67 posted on 06/19/2004 3:18:35 PM PDT by McGruff
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 65 | View Replies]

To: turbocat

Kakutani rules! I have always thought she is an excellent book reviewer, she never pulls a punch. I am so glad they gave it to her to review, and I think she's put it fairly, all around.

She's also made me want to read US Grant's autobiography.


68 posted on 06/19/2004 3:20:55 PM PDT by jocon307 (help....I lost my tagline! wait I found it: Immigration Moratorium NOW!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: goldstategop

"This is one memoir that can be safely said to be written by its subject."

Yes, let's give old Bill some credit for that while we're having fun reading the pans!


69 posted on 06/19/2004 3:22:24 PM PDT by jocon307 (help....I lost my tagline! wait I found it: Immigration Moratorium NOW!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies]

To: AM2000

A reviewer with integrity. Wow. Nothing like a stream of conscienceness autobigraphy with the world's most garralous and self-absorbed man.


70 posted on 06/19/2004 3:24:58 PM PDT by Ruth A.
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: nwrep

I hope she doesn't get Arkancided.


71 posted on 06/19/2004 3:49:15 PM PDT by Ann Archy (Abortion: The Human Sacrifice to the god of Convenience.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: nwrep
I hope Michiko is polishing up her resume, because she will not last very long at the New York Times.

Nah -- now if she panned HILLARY! and The Big He, she'd need to get a new job.

72 posted on 06/19/2004 3:51:25 PM PDT by mrustow ("And when Moses saw the golden calf, he shouted out to the heavens, 'Jesus, Mary, and Joseph!'")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: rmgatto
Good writing. This reporter has the talent necessary for a move up to a major paper.

Spewing. That's really funny!

73 posted on 06/19/2004 3:55:54 PM PDT by Aeronaut (I think I'll just go lie by my dish and whimper.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 13 | View Replies]

To: AM2000

I am devastated. I was so looking forward to a good read. Now what?
well, there' always Louis L'Amour


74 posted on 06/19/2004 3:56:52 PM PDT by beebuster2000 (the only thing quagmired is the lib mind)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Miss Marple
He does a persuasive job of explicating his more successful initiatives like welfare reform and deficit reduction

Shoved down his throat by the GOP!!!

I heard that he says that when he tried to tell George W. Bush that bin Laden was the bigget threat to this country that Bush changed the subject.

And repeated again in this "telling" is the story of watching Martin Luther King's speech at the Lincoln Memorial live on TV in his living room in Little Rock; I'm almost positive that lie has been put to rest right here on FR.

75 posted on 06/19/2004 3:59:08 PM PDT by Howlin
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: Wild Irish Rogue
zombies in Haiti and ruins in Pompeii

This guy seems to think that everything in time and space involve him.

76 posted on 06/19/2004 3:59:25 PM PDT by bannie (Liberal Media: The Most Dangerous Enemies to America and Freedom)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: Wild Irish Rogue

I wonder if Gennifer Flowers in included in this huge volume.


77 posted on 06/19/2004 4:01:04 PM PDT by bannie (Liberal Media: The Most Dangerous Enemies to America and Freedom)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: Carolinamom; All
Approbiate picture I think



78 posted on 06/19/2004 4:01:11 PM PDT by Kaslin
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 63 | View Replies]

To: Wild Irish Rogue

I still have problems imagining Bubba being interested in any woman large enough that he could fit into her undies. Maybe Monica in her Anna Nicole Smith period, but she wasn't that big when she was working for him.


79 posted on 06/19/2004 4:03:12 PM PDT by RichInOC (Ronald Wilson Reagan, 2/6/11-6/5/04, R.I.P.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 39 | View Replies]

To: NormsRevenge
Here's an even better definition:

pastiche

Main Entry: pas·tiche
Pronunciation: pas-'tEsh, päs-
Function: noun
Etymology: French, from Italian pasticcio
1 : a literary, artistic, musical, or architectural work that imitates the style of previous work; also : such stylistic imitation
2 a : a musical, literary, or artistic composition made up of selections from different works : POTPOURRI b : HODGEPODGE

In other words, slung together!

80 posted on 06/19/2004 4:03:39 PM PDT by Howlin
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 32 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 41-6061-8081-100 ... 121-132 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson