Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: AntiGuv
(Just a couple of drive-by comments for the moment. I'll try to address the substance of your post tonight.)

In the first instance, we are simply assuming that information may be transmitted via quantum entanglement regardless of whether that is ever proven true in actuality.

Well, don't assume that, because it is definitively known that entanglement cannot be used to transmit information. But I know what you mean: we'll put our foot down, like Ursula LeGuin, and say "an ansible exists! Now what?"

Now as for the second issue, I simply want to reiterate that quantum mechanics and special relativity are not a unified theory; the two cannot be encompassed within a single known mathematical framework. The very phenomenon of quantum entanglement underscores that discrepancy and indeed its conjectured existence first made that clear. We cannot use the discordance between quantum mechanics and special relativity

Stop right there. There is no discrepancy between special relativity and quantum mechanics. Entanglement does not violate SR, because it cannot lead to non-causal physical behaviors. It's just a correlation.

[Geek alert: The famed discrepancy between relativity and quantum mechanics is between General Relativity and Quantum Field Theory. You see, in QFT, the forces are described by the exchange of particles called bosons. The physical quantities we calculate are based on a superposition of all possible boson exchanges; this infinite sum is kept finite by a method called renormalization. It works incredibly well for all forces besides gravity. Now, what about gravity? Because of the geometry of the Einstein Field Equations, the bosons of any quantized gravity force would be spin-2, meaning that each boson would carry twice as much angular momentum as a photon (a boson of electromagnetism). Here's the problem: spin-2 forces aren't renormalizable in the 4-dimensional spacetime we observe. In fact, there are only two spaces in which a spin-2 force can be finite: one space has 26 dimensions, and the other space has 11. (Sound familiar?)]

286 posted on 06/19/2004 3:05:51 PM PDT by Physicist
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 267 | View Replies ]


To: Physicist
Stop right there. There is no discrepancy between special relativity and quantum mechanics. Entanglement does not violate SR, because it cannot lead to non-causal physical behaviors. It's just a correlation.

OK, well I can accept that. But my understanding is that quantum entanglement is generally thought to be invariant within special relativity. That is what I meant. Is this incorrect?

Geek alert:

Indeed!! j/k =)

287 posted on 06/19/2004 4:16:57 PM PDT by AntiGuv (When the countdown hits zero - something's gonna happen..)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 286 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson