[FairOpinion]

"Treatment of such prisoners has nothing to do with what they did or who they are or whether they are animals or not. "

Like heck, it doesn't. You keep confusing legitimate POW-s with terrorists.

[Arkinsaw]

Like heck, it doesn't. You keep confusing legitimate POW-s with terrorists.

I'm not confusing anything. Like I said, it makes no difference who the prisoner is, it matters who we are.

American servicemembers are under order not to abuse any prisoner regardless of who they are. They took an oath not to disobey legal orders. If they do so they are disobeying a direct order and violating their oath.

You can't tell jack squat from photos. They provide absolutely no context. But in general, you can't disobey orders and violate your oath and get a free pass.