[Razwan]

Why is everyone assuming that these were some peaceful Iraqi civilians that the soldiers decided to torture?

Why is it that torture in any circumstance is ok with you? We need to be better than them, not sink to a lower level.

military interrogator here. been there, done that, got the t-shirts

[FairOpinion]

"Why is it that torture in any circumstance is ok with you? "


===

Have we been inundated by Al Qaeda moles or something?!

Don't you think torture is quite justified to get terrorists to tell about imminent terror plots against us, which may kill hundreds or more people?

How do you think Jordan got the terrorists to tell them all about their chemical attack plan, which may have killed close to 100,000 people, if it had succeeded?

Do you think terrorists shouldn't be tortured, we should let them kills tens of thousands of innocents instead?

[Michael Barnes]

Just curious, when did ya serve? How many enemy soldiers did you interogate?

(Not being snide, serious question)