Posted on 03/15/2004 1:49:26 AM PST by goldstategop
Oscar Honors a Nazi March 1, 2004
Hitlers favorite propagandist has finally been rehabilitated.
At Sundays Academy Awards ceremony, Hollywood gave Leni Riefenstahl its kosher seal of approval.
As it does every year, the Oscars ceremony paid homage and tribute to all of the great actors, directors, composers, and other showbiz types who passed on in the previous year.
But along with recently deceased legends like Bob Hope, Gregory Peck, Donald OConnor, Robert Stack, Buddy Hackett -- and even John Ritter, Ms. Riefenstahl was so honored.
Incredibly, the Hollywood audience in attendance gave loud applause in response to the televised photo and name of the German filmmaker who used concentration camp prisoners as extras.
Should Hollywoods most important institution accord any recognition to this woman?
Riefenstahl claimed she was never a Nazi and didnt sympathize with Hitler, but her actions and statements indicate otherwise. During the Nazi era, Riefenstahl:
was personally hand-picked by Hitler to make films glorifying Hitler, the Nazi party, and the infamous Nazi-run Berlin Olympics, at which Jews were excluded. (In 1932, Hitler told her, "Once we come to power, you must make my films.")
received financing for several of her films from Nazi propaganda officer Goebbels and his Ministry.
"employed" Gypsy prisoners of concentration camps as extras in her films, their last stop before deportation to Nazi death camps where half of them were exterminated.
Deleted the names of Jewish co-writers from her first film, "The Blue Light" when it was re-issued in 1938.
Riefenstahl "played a leading role in making propaganda for the most evil regime in human history," said Dr. Rafael Medoff, director of the David S. Wyman Institute for Holocaust Studies, in protesting the Academy recognition.
Would someone worthy of Academy Award tribute utter these famous Reifenstahlisms about Hitler?:
"Your deeds exceed the power of human imagination. They are without equal in the history of mankind. How can we ever thank you?" (1940 telegram from Riefenstahl congratulating Hitler on conquering Paris)
"I must confess that I was so impressed by you and by the enthusiasm of the spectators that I would like to meet you personally."
"That evening I felt that Hitler desired me as a woman" (regarding one of her many meetings with Hitler, though she denied they were lovers).
Was it ignorance, or just "the Academys" insistence on judging the art and not the artist?
If the standard is the latter, then Hollywood has a more lax standard for Nazis than for anti-Communists.
Remember Elia Kazan? He also died in 2003 and was part of the televised memorial honor roll that included Riefenstahl, Sunday.
But in 2002, actors like Nick Nolte, Ed Harris, Amy Madigan, and Ed Begley, Jr. protested the Lifetime Achievement Oscar that masterful director Kazan received. They sat on their hands, faces angry with rage, as Kazan took the stage to accept his award. They couldnt forgive Kazans anti-Communist patriotism and his testimony before the House Committee on Un-American Activities at the height of the Cold War.
In left-wing Hollywoods eyes, Kazans magnificent films, "A Streetcar Named Desire," "East of Eden," and, ironically, "Gentlemans Agreement" (an ahead of its time film decrying anti-Semitism) were irrelevant. His talent wasnt as important as his naming names of members of the Communist Party even though the Venona Papers revealed that those he named were in fact Communists working to overthrow the U.S.
No such outrage from the entertainment industrys liberal elite for the Nazi filmmaker who glorified the genocide of six million Jews and the murder of five million others.
No actors sitting on their hands. Just lots of applause.
The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has a strange version of exclusivity.
The Wall Street Journal, Friday, detailed comedian Rob Schneiders failed repeat bids for membership in the Academy. While its membership includes that "fine actor", Martin Lawrence, and now honors a Nazi propagandist, the Oscar purveyor is too highbrow to accept the likes of Schneider, whose movies make whopping multi-millions.
The Academy "will find it easier to endorse you for membership once youve turned in a strong performance . . . that showcases additional strengths."
"What the hell was I thinking, wanting to join an organization like that, anyway?" Schneider asked. "My thanks to the remarkably distinguished committee of actors for considering me (Ed Begley, Jr.?)."
If only hed taken some money from Goebbels and added a "Heil Hitler" to the "Deuce Bigalow, Male Gigolo" sequel hes now filming.
You are right on! What's next a Joseph Goebbels Public Speaker Award?
Sun Times excerpt review by Roger Ebert
""Triumph of the Will" (1934) was a film about the Nazi Party Congress in Nuremberg, an event largely staged for the benefit of her camera, which showed a confident Hitler nodding approvingly as massed ranks of Nazi troops march in review. Three years later, she directed "Olympia," a documentary on the Berlin Olympiad.
These are by general consent two of the best documentaries ever made. But because they reflect the ideology of a monstrous movement, they pose a classic question of the contest between art and morality: Is there such a thing as pure art, or does all art make a political statement?
Riefenstahl is at pains to insist she was never a member of the Nazi Party. Her position has always been that she was an artist, working in a vacuum. The tragedy of her career, from her view, is that "Triumph of the Will" and "Olympia" gained such fame, and were so closely identified with Nazism, that she was never able to finish another film. There were other documentaries about the Nazi rallies, but nobody remembers the others; only hers, because it was so good.
"The Wonderful Horrible Life of Leni Riefenstahl" is not convinced by her lifelong self-justification, and subjects her to strenuous on-camera questioning. She is unyielding. More than able at the age of 91 to defend herself, she has rehearsed over the years an elaborate explanation and justification for her behavior. There is no mention in her films of anti-Semitism, she points out. She did not know until after the war about Hitler's genocidal policies against the Jews. She was a naive artist, unsophisticated about politics, detached from Nazi party officials with the exception of Hitler, her friend - but not a close friend. She was concerned only with images, not ideas.
And so on. But it has been pointed out that the very absence of anti-Semitism in "Triumph of the Will" looks like a calculation; excluding the central motif of almost all of Hitler's public speeches must have been a deliberate decision to make the film more efficient as propaganda. Nor could it have been easy for a film professional working in Berlin to remain unaware of the disappearance of all of the Jews in the movie industry."
As Susan Sontag (vile witch of postmodernism that she may be) pointed out, Riefenstahl continued to be obsessed about racial grandeur and purity after the war, as was demonstrated by her photography and film making in Africa.
By the way, the Masai are interesting, so it's hard to fault her too much for her pictures. It's just such a coincidence...
They did not do any such thing. All they did was acknowledge her passing, just as they do for everyone of name in the world of motion pictures that has passed on during the previous year.
As I said during the Official Oscars thread, instead of putting her name up, they should have simply said, "A Nazi." And no further comment is needed.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.