re: James Caroll
It always amazes me how many "religious" like Caroll (the Berrigans, et alia) have given up the Church, but cannot let go of the magisterium.
They have abandoned the truth, and transformed their authority into a shrill and bitter arrogance.
I take it that you then read his review of this film? It was the worst by far because it was written by someone who obviously is well aware of traditional Catholic theology unlike many of the Jewish or non religious critics. I can't fathom how he could write such a review? His hatreds are deep. In fact- If you read between the lines it is Carroll whom I suspect has a problem with the "Jews" rather than Gibson.