[Tricorn]

"The fact that the Eagles managed to earn the best record in the NFC and make it to the championship game this year without nearly as good a defense as it had the previous two years is simply icing on the cake to prove Rush wrong in saying McNabb gets credit he doesn't deserve."

Is this the new standard when judging QBs? What was Feeley's record when he took over for McNabb last year? McNabb, by this new criteria, is still looking up at Trent Dilfer -- in fact most QBs in the league still don't rate as highly as Dilfer, who never got the credit he deserved. How about Brad Johnson? Is McNabb better than Brad Johnson?

[jragan2001]

A.J. Feely was 5-1 last year in McNabb's absence. And don't forget in Koy Detmer's one game in SF before he
got injured, he threw three TD passes in helping Philly
blow out SF on MNF.