Skip to comments.
The Lord of the Rings: A Catholic View
The Cool-Ohm Zone ^
| --
| Charles Coulombe
Posted on 01/04/2004 11:33:19 PM PST by B-Chan
click here to read article
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61 next last
Politically, traditional Catholic culture has been hierarchical. Feudalism itself was formed in great degree by the Faith, as is shown by the great difference between the Feudal system of European history, and its equivalents in the India of the Mughals, the Japan of the Tokugawa, and the China of the Warring States. Ideas of Chivalry and Hierarchy suggested by the Church did not merely shape European Catholic polity, but continue to determine political structures in such settings as Catholicised African tribes, ethnic Catholic Asian settlements, and Latin America. The relationships of King to Subject, of Lord to Vassal, of Comrade to Comrade-in-Arms remain, though often under other names.
In traditional Catholic societies, the King is, in a lessened sense, the Vicar of God. While not approximating the Sacral Kingship of non-Catholic peoples, the Catholic Monarchy nevertheless retains a certain sacredness. This remains the case, even when in conflict with the Church. After the calamities of the Reformation, English Civil War, Glorious, French, Industrial, and Russian Revolutions, etc., the King became more than that; he became the exiled leader of the faithful, whose return alone would bring a return to the old ways, and an end to change and unrest.
[...]
The concept of society as an organic whole, without class conflict, with a communal structure, is one that has characterised Catholic social thought since the Roman Empire. In many ways the Shire expresses perfectly the economic and political ideals of the Church, as expressed by Leo XIII in Rerum novarum, and Pius XI in Quadragesimo anno. Traditional authority (the Thain), limited except in times of crisis; popular representation (the Mayor of Michel Delving), likewise limited; subsidiarity; and above all, minimal organisation and conflict. It is the sort of society envisioned by Distributists Belloc and Chesterton in Britain, by Salazar in Portugal, by the framers of the Irish Constitution, by Dollfuss in Austria, and by Smetona in Lithuania. How ever far short or close these dwellers in the real world came to their goal, the fact remains that it is something very close to the Shire they had in mind.
1
posted on
01/04/2004 11:33:19 PM PST
by
B-Chan
To: All
2
posted on
01/04/2004 11:33:42 PM PST
by
Support Free Republic
(I'd rather be sleeping. Let's get this over with so I can go back to sleep!)
To: B-Chan
Karl Rove is Grima Wormtongue. I sure hope Gandalf and Aragorn arrive soon to wake up Theoden Bush.
3
posted on
01/05/2004 12:02:00 AM PST
by
Xthe17th
("What is the use of being elected or re-elected unless you stand for something?" - Grover Cleveland)
To: B-Chan
Wow! Great find.
In his Hieroglyphics: Notes on the Ecstatic in Literature, Mr. Arthur Machen declares, "Literature is the expression, through the artistic medium of words, of the dogmas of the Catholic Church, and that which is in anyway out of harmony with these dogmas is not literature," for "Catholic dogma is merely the witness, under a special symbolism of the enduring facts of human nature and the universe."
4
posted on
01/05/2004 12:17:02 AM PST
by
polemikos
(Ecce Agnus Dei)
To: HairOfTheDog; ecurbh
Pingpingping!
5
posted on
01/05/2004 12:37:59 AM PST
by
Rose in RoseBear
(HHD [I just like looking at 'em, but I think this guy is purdy!])
To: Serb5150
pingin' ya...)
6
posted on
01/05/2004 12:39:18 AM PST
by
jwfiv
To: Tax-chick; Tax Deduction 1
PING
7
posted on
01/05/2004 2:24:21 AM PST
by
Huber
(Charge the RINOs!)
To: B-Chan
Good article, thanks for posting.
8
posted on
01/05/2004 3:13:55 AM PST
by
Smocker
To: B-Chan
Isn't this just Richard Wagner re-worked.
Das est 'Gau' ideas at it's 'roots'.
The mythical 'Volk' earth-spirits moving again?
Sure isn't the 'work' of America's Founding Fathers is it?
Just more media brainwashing...(rewriting/rejecting) 'history'?
/sarcasm
9
posted on
01/05/2004 3:36:12 AM PST
by
maestro
To: maestro
Not merely, re-worked but
negated.
See: http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Front_Page/EA11Aa02.html
To: B-Chan
Just this previous weekend the family and I saw "Return of the King". Probably the most amazing thing to me about these three stories is the number of moral lessons they offer. Two that occured to me during the movie were:
- The price of apathy is blood - the accumulation of evil in Mordor was characterized as being attributable to man's inattentiveness.
- Strength of character trumps physical strength - Only the virtuous Frodo was capable of carrying the ring, even though he was physically perhaps the weakest.
11
posted on
01/05/2004 3:46:13 AM PST
by
The Duke
To: The Duke
ping
12
posted on
01/05/2004 3:55:16 AM PST
by
TomSmedley
((technical writer looking for work!))
To: Tax-chick
Later
13
posted on
01/05/2004 4:04:16 AM PST
by
Tax-chick
(I reserve the right to disclaim all January 2004 posts after the BABY is born!)
To: 2Jedismom; 300winmag; Alkhin; Alouette; ambrose; Anitius Severinus Boethius; artios; AUsome Joy; ...
14
posted on
01/05/2004 5:00:29 AM PST
by
ecurbh
To: ecurbh; Alkhin
I saw the Flat Frodo at Alkhin's house... Neat idea!
Ping, Alkhin!!!!
15
posted on
01/05/2004 5:38:53 AM PST
by
buffyt
(You don't have a leg to stand on, Howard Dean, because you have both feet in your mouth!)
Comment #16 Removed by Moderator
To: B-Chan
The fact that "LOTR" and "The Passion of Jesus Christ," probably the two greatest "Catholic" movies in history, are coming out at the same time cannot be a coincidence.
17
posted on
01/05/2004 6:46:44 AM PST
by
Aquinasfan
(Isaiah 22:22, Rev 3:7, Mat 16:19)
To: TonyRo76
I have had the privilege of meeting one person worthy--and theoretically capable of inheriting--a crown. It is indeed something rather amazing to encounter true Royalty (and not just weenieized petit nobility, the less we have of the better).
However, I agree with you: America has no place for a monarchy because we ELECT our King... and sometimes, (oh, abuot 2000 or so) God elects one for us in spite of ourselves.
To: Huber
I guess I'm just too Protestant for this stuff, or maybe I was exposed to P.J. O'Rourke when I was too young :-).
I've read LOTR a number of times, but more recently it's been mainly for the language, and for a few characters and episodes that I particularly like. The "important, meaningful" characters and events just irritate or depress me. Maybe it's a personal flaw that I should reflect upon ...
19
posted on
01/05/2004 8:36:11 AM PST
by
Tax-chick
(I reserve the right to disclaim all January 2004 posts after the BABY is born!)
To: TonyRo76
I don't know much about Tom Paine's religious views, but Tom Jefferson's ... let's just say that one of his projects was "editing" his own "version" of the Gospels, by trimming out the parts he didn't like with a knife.
If you believe that Christianity is true, then you ought to take what Jefferson says about any topic with a grain or two of salt ... because he didn't.
20
posted on
01/05/2004 8:44:22 AM PST
by
Campion
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson