Replies

DANG!!!

You got a HUNDRED replies alREADY???!!

Ok, I'll wade in...

The Downfall of Uniformitarianism 11/04/2003
Can major paradigm shifts occur in science today? Check this one out.
You’ve seen it on TV science programs and in textbooks: plumes of hot magma from deep in the Earth’s mantle rise through the crust and erupt on the surface (the IMAX movie Yellowstone has computer graphics of the whole process). Perhaps you’ve seen animations of the Hawaiian Islands riding over a “hot spot” and building its chain of volcanoes over millions of years on its slow, drifting journey. Textbook diagrams show cross-sections of Earth’s crust, with lava erupting from channels rooted deep in the mantle, while crustal plates float and drift atop deep convection currents.
That’s all defunct now, and so is a lot of the uniformitarian dogma associated with it, claims Warren B. Hamilton (Colorado School of Mines), in an extensive article in this month’s GSA Today.¹ Uniformitarianism is out, catastrophism is in. Now, don’t get the idea Hamilton denies the Earth is billions of years old; he still accepts the 4.567 billion year figure, the condensation of Earth from a solar nebula, and all that.

1. Leaving the question of where did the solar nebula come from, just give me a clue as to how HOT each little speck of dust was as it coalesced.

2. Archimaeides(sp?) (I think) said that if he had a place to put a fulcrum, he could move the Earth with a lever. I want to know: A. what FORCE is causing the 'plates to move' and B. what is it pushing against.

3. Assuming the Earth WAS a redhole ball of 'stuff' 4.5 BYA, why hasn't it cooled off by now? As fast as the daily heat goes away if there is no cloud cover at night, it should be solid by now, not filled with red-hot rock just WAITING to blast out!

(You've probably already figured out that 'redhole' should be redhot.......)

You got a HUNDRED replies alREADY???!!

Your attention to detail astounds me. :-)

What, more questions with just-so scientific answers?