Posted on 09/01/2012 1:23:06 PM PDT by 2ndDivisionVet
As I mentioned in my last post, I missed part of the line-up last night. I got back just in time to see Clint Eastwood offer up one more “Make my day,” and then watch the deluge of criticism roll across Twitter. It continues today at Time Magazine, where Michael Grunwald calls it a “train wreck,” and goes a little Chris Matthews for good measure:
Oh my. Romney’s speech sounded fine, and Marco Rubio seemed quite eloquent, but honestly, all I can think about is Dirty Harry scolding an invisible president in a chair for making an anatomically impossible suggestion. We had heard there would be a surprise guest tonight, but apparently, the surprise was a surprise to the surprise guest. You know how reporters always complain that conventions are too scripted? Eastwood was the first thing on network TV tonight, and oh, it wasn’t scripted. It wasn’t rehearsed. It wasn’t sane. …
There was one semi-disturbing moment, when Clint screamed “We own this country!” He got a standing ovation for that one, and it’s possible that the virtually all-white crowd was picking up a bit of Gran Torino you-know-what-I-mean-by-we. But I would chalk it up to incoherence rather than malice, because that was definitely the theme of his soliloquy.
The “sane” world understood that as a reference to the taxpayers as opposed to the political class, actually, and the theme of Gran Torino wasn’t a paean to xenophobia, either. In fact, that’s nearly a direct antithesis of its message. It doesn’t get much better over at National Journal’s roundup of reactions, either:
The reviews continue to pour in on Clint Eastwood’s appearance at the Republican National convention Thursday night, and “mixed” might be a charitable way to put it. One prominent Republican, Gov. Scott Walker of Wisconsin, said that he “cringed” at the performance.
Walker, appearing on MSNBC’s Morning Joe on Friday, echoed the sentiments of many when he said he would have preferred to see more testimonials from people talking about Romney. “Frankly I would have rather seen that than Clint Eastwood,” he said. …
Eastwood’s performance, a rambling 12-minute discourse that featured the legendary actor and Oscar-winning director talking to an empty chair that represented President Obama, dominated Twitter and other social media sites.
The Romney campaign explained it best:
“Judging an American icon like Clint Eastwood through a typical political lens doesn’t work. His ad-libbing was a break from all the political speeches, and the crowd enjoyed it.”
Perhaps the initial reaction from people came from the immediacy of the moment, and an expectation that a lifelong entertainer had come to do something other than, er, entertain. Plenty of criticism in my Twitter feed came from people who support Mitt Romney, too. But having watched it this morning, after all of the drama has passed, I actually thought Eastwood was … pretty funny. It was refreshing to get that break from all of the seriousness of the three days in Tampa. The clucking of tongues over Eastwood’s “I can’t do that to myself” as inappropriate is almost laughable, considering what passes for humor these days in the US. Eastwood intended this to be irreverent, spontaneous, and fun. If you didn’t get at least three laughs out of that 11-minute segment, you’re taking life too seriously.
If I can riff like that on national TV at the age of 82, believe me, I’ll be happy.
One criticism is more substantial, which is that this kind of break from seriousness should have been scheduled earlier in the evening. That misses the point of having Eastwood on the stage at all. Michael Walsh explains it at the New York Post:
To see why the choice of Clint Eastwood as the surprise guest speaker at last night’s close of the Republican Convention was so brilliant, look at the electoral map. …
In other words, the Heartland Campaign is not simply about Electoral College votes. It’s also a way to frame the Democrats as the out-of-touch party of the status quo — i.e., Big Government — at a time when Big Government has so signally failed the average American.
If it works — and if a Romney administration can successfully grapple with the debt bomb, the entitlement crisis and growing government dependency — it could set back the Democrats’ prospects for years to come.
Which brings us back to Eastwood. In such films as “The Outlaw Josey Wales” and “High Plains Drifter,” he’s the embodiment of rugged, rebellious heartland values.
And those cranky, cantankerous, all-American voters are just who Romney & Ryan need to defeat the coastal elites and return America to its heartland roots.
Besides the Heartland Strategy, the RNC and Team Romney was using the Eyeball Strategy. They needed to reach people who might not have otherwise tuned in to the Republican convention to see Marco Rubio and Mitt Romney. That means putting their Eyeball Strategy in play directly before Rubio. Now, perhaps some people who tuned in to see Hollywood icon Clint Eastwood speak tuned out after (or even during), but it’s a no-lose strategy. They wouldn’t lose anyone who tuned in to see Romney and Rubio anyway, and there’s a very good chance that most of the people who tuned in for Eastwood stuck around for Rubio and Romney afterward. If they did, they saw two terrific speeches and perhaps had their minds opened about Romney after Barack Obama’s summer of vilification.
That’s brilliant. As for the handwringing over Eastwood’s extemporaneous riff, I can only say this:
(VIDEO AT LINK)
HOORAY Ed! HOORAY Clint!
Scott Walker was born in ‘67, it was probably a little over his head. He was barely an indecent thought during the spaghetti westerns, was making mudpies during Dirty Harry, and was a 9 year old for Josey Wales.
Freakin’ kids, should be seen and not heard sometmes.
Well, the polls are showing it. A canvas of Florida voters showed he improved independent turnovers to the GOP by 10%. That was on an earlier thread this morning.
It was a brilliant, staged performance.
The Dem "talking heads" and surrogates just can't bring themselves to acknowledge that the entire world "got" Eastwood's message loud and clear--and they have nowhere to hide.
Agree, too, with Applegateranch's comments on another thread about the genius of Eastwood's use of his object's own "egregious speech pattern," commonly referred to by pseudointellectual "progressives" as a sign of Obama's great intellect and deliberative style. Now, Eastwood's use of it, with "progressives" (an entire set of "empty chairs" when it comes to understanding and defending the ideas of freedom), such a "deliberate" and halting style denotes everything from senility to "doddering fool."
Another gem was his use of a former President's assessment of Romney's "stellar business performance" in this total unmasking of the great destroyer of business in America. Bet Hillary, the eye-rolling "You know what I mean" Hillary, got it too, from wherever she was watching.
From Geraldo Rivera on FOX to Gloria Borger on CNN, the faux criticism and claims that Eastwood distracted from the Romney speech and Borger's claim that parts were "crass" are laughable when compared with much of the Dem performer language and inferences.
This was a priceless and iconic performance which will live on, long after Eastwood is gone, and Obama is a distant memory in the rearview mirror of presidents.
scott walker needs to brush up on the classics.
I was able to see the Clint Eastwood special, plus Marco Rubio and Mitt Rommey speeches! They were all excellent!
I think voters have got the message: “Both parties must focus getting the job done!
Politics, nor politicians, nor speeches, nor titles etc. count!
What our nation really needs is: “JUST GETTING THE JOB DONE”
I was glad it was something an artist did, and not some stodgy serious straight guy speech. It was like he was some guy cutting up in your living room.
And i almost passed out laughing when he came out with that, “well he can’t do that to himself”,,,,”you sound crazy” schtik.
Agree. Walker's a bit young, a bit too quick to respond -- he should've held back on this one.
At first I found Eastwood's performance "cringe"-worthy too. But after thinking about it overnight, I did a 180.
"Getting" the brilliance of Clint's performance is kind of like "getting" new and odd-sounding music. Sometimes it takes a few listenings before the new musical patterns start to register in your mind -- and then you fall in love with them, and can't get enough.
It wasn't. All planned, down to the last detail, even the MUSSED UP HAIR.
Good post!
Governor Walker should understand, that there are times when one should keep their opinions to themselves.
I think the empty chair representing Obama in a discussion with Eastwood was the surprise guest, NOT Eastwood.
Everyone missed the joke!
I'm just surprised at the number of Republicans that can't make the connection.
Military Channel showing Clint Eastwood,s “Heartbreak Ridge” right now.
Military Channel showing Clint Eastwood,s “Heartbreak Ridge” right now.
Military Channel showing Clint Eastwood,s “Heartbreak Ridge” right now.
I don’t know. I like Eastwood on the screen or at a piano, and he wasn’t outrageous Thursday night; but I doubt that he lit up the crowd any better than Sarah would have. Criminally myopic bots.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.