[jazzlite]

If Miss American is judged on more than just physical appearance, what should the American Idol not be judged on more than just a singing voice? My vote goes to Josh.

[heylady]

I agree. This week I will vote for Josh. The song he sang on Wednesday night was great. Ruben is one dimentional..a Barry White wannabee. Funny that Simon is eager to tell the females to loose weight but seems to have no problem with Ruben's total inability to move on stage.