Replies

I would like to hear from Bilbo when the elves are leaving. When they showed scenes of Rivendell in TTT, it lookied like everyone was leaving and they had shut the lights off! I know they didn't go off and leave him! They have to wait till Frodo gets back.

And I would also love the scene with the release of the horse. It was described as a beautiful scene in some spoilers I read. The horse was described as emotionally and physically wounded... battle-shocked. And Aragorn freed him from further service. I am a horse lover, so that makes me teary just thinking about it!

And the Faramir scene sounds very poignant! - These are men, after all, not Orcs. What would possess a man to serve Sauron?

I agree, the whole Rivendell situation could use some beefing up, while we're unconcerned about length.

So could the character of Faramir. The addition of the scenes I mentioned, along with those of he and his family, would be most welcome to most "purists" AND movie-fans alike.