Well... if you want to hear something really cool...
I was the one who suggested we exchange Christmas presents that first time. Since I knew she liked teddy bears, picking out a present was fairly easy: I got her a cute teddy bear, boxed it up, and sent it on its way. I got her present on the day I was to travel to my parents house for Christmas (I was living about 100 miles away from them at that time). We didn't wait for Christmas day, but opened them then, while we were both online.
It turned out we sent each other the same bear... almost. Physically, there were identical, except for one difference: the one I sent her was brown, and the one she sent me was cream-colored. Anyone who's seen our picture knows how significant that little detail is. ;)
After that, we kinda knew we had something special!