Replies

I liked him! - First impression, he was painted as more harshly changed than he really was. I think his attitude was reasonable and believable. I don't have a problem with his words and actions. I am not sure why we had to go to Osgoliath. What happened there could have happened anywhere, and they could have saved one whole extra set piece.

In this film, I could see the cuts, unlike FoTR. In other words... I think I saw where dialogue was missing that probably happened. I can picture the Extended DVD on this one, where I couldn't tell exactly was missing in FoTR, except for the gift scene, which we knew about.
Does that make sense? - Maybe not, until you have seen it.