[HairOfTheDog]

Yes, written by a guy who wanted to like it!

It is interesting to see people's innate pessimism or optimism come out in their reviews of something like this.

The review from Harry's site was written by someone who seemingly wanted to be pleased but made it a tough challenge, I think this guy it seems simply sat back and allowed the film to please him. He didn't have the baggage of feeling he had to be won over on it.

Interesting to me that he is writing it from the point of view of someone who has "read the book" but he has not yet finished his reading. He read Two Towers to prep for the movie, but doesn't know how the story ends in the book. It gives him an interesting take on the relative significance of events.

[maquiladora]

Yes, I agree, it's a relief to read this one, the review on Harry's site was shakey to say the least and not very comprehensive.
But this is great stuff, the first review from a real critic, and it gives it 5 stars and calls it a masterpiece!

What more could we want! This is fantastic! All worries / fears are gone, bring on the movie!

[Overtaxed]

Elrond made a decision, and that decision was to help.

Well it's about time! :)

No mention of Pippin and the Palantir?