To: Mike Darancette
When I visited the Gettysburg battlefield, I took a long and hard look at both the Round Tops. Little RT had a panoramic view of the entire area and was a critical point, to be sure. Big RT I don't perceive as being any better than LRT for the same purpose, plus it's heavily wooded thus getting any significant artillery up there was out of the question. LRT would have blocked the line of sight of BRT to the rest of the Union line, in any case.
To: thescourged1
Big RT I don't perceive as being any better than LRT for the same purpose, plus it's heavily wooded thus getting any significant artillery up there was out of the question. Big RT overlooks Little RT the Confederates could have attacked Little RT from two sides.
This will be a point for discussion whenever tactics are talked about. What-If ......
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson