Personally, I happen to think we are in a golden age of new talent coming into baseball. Last year's rookie crop and this year's both look to me to be completely loaded.
Anyhow, I highly recommend the Baseball Prospectus website and book to any hardcore baseball fans.
Here is the table from early in it, done right:
Season League Winner Others 1995 AL Marty Cordova Shawn Green (fifth) 1994 AL Bob Hamelin Jim Edmonds (eighth) 1990 AL Sandy Alomar Jr. Robin Ventura (seventh) 1989 AL Gregg Olson Ken Griffey Jr. (third), Kevin Brown (sixth) 1986 NL Todd Worrell Barry Bonds (sixth), Barry Larkin (eighth)
The classic example of a "Rookie of the Year" who got there with his career year: Joe Charboneau.
-Eric