Posted on 11/20/2026 11:45:32 PM PST by dangus
The era of football teams getting promoted into the major conferences is probably over. The decent programs from torn apart conferences and independents have mostly found homes: Miami, Boston College, Syracuse, Pittsburgh, West Virginia, Louisville, Rutgers, TCU, Utah, BYU, Baylor, Houston. The major conferences seem full, TV contracts are locked in for several years, and there just aren't enough teams left to cobble together something like a New Big East. But there are still some orphan programs (Memphis), some guaranteed draws (East Carolina, South Florida), the academies (Navy, Army, Air Force), and some newer schools capable of doing big things (App State, Liberty, JMU).
There's no rhyme or reason to these conferences. Apart from the Mid American Conference, They were mostly hobbled together quickly when the NCAA demanded 12-team conferences in order to host a conference championship, a requirement no longer in play. And they desperately sought to stay sufficiently large as their best teams were raided. What are left are bloated, hodge-podge conferences with no commonality in competitiveness, geography, history or mission. The constitutions they signed to keep teams reluctant from jumping have become death pacts, preventing common-sense realignment.
They do have one commonality which might help matters, however: East of the Rockies, their TV contracts are all with ESPN, making renegotiation very possible. So what if instead of hostile raids, they work together? What if instead of trying to build bigger and bigger conferences in doomed attempts to gobble enough competitive teams, they went for smaller conferences which were structured so that the top teams could face each other outside of conference schedules?
The first surprise to me is that this would be permitted within the NCAA: The top team from one conference schedule a game with the top team from another. #2 faces #2, #3 faces #3, and so forth. The reason this isn't done is simply logistical, since it's impossible to find match-ups for all the teams. But if conferences were small and consistently sized, it could work. The small sizes would allow pure round-robin schedules, with time for matchups against two other conferences, and still time for two truly free games, for specific rivalries or games versus Power Four conferences.
It's difficult for conferences to improve themselves when that means raiding other conferences, restructuring to improve rivalries or matchups, or dropping weaklings. The teams which would get the short end of the stick have the ability to block such restructuring, so instead what you get are hefty exit fees and long-term contracts. But this proposal allows such improvements in TV contracts, match-ups, more local games for fans, travel costs costs, there are no pure losers.
So here are the proposed conferences:
East (Army, Memphis, Navy, South Florida, Temple, Liberty, UConn, James Madison)
Cattle (North Texas, Rice, Tulsa, UT San Antonio, Sam Houston, Tulane, Tarleton St., New Mexico State)
South Atlantic (Old Dominion, Charlotte, Coastal Carolina, Delaware, Florida Atlantic, Florida Interrnational, Georgia Southern, East Carolina)
South (App State, Marshall, Western Kentucky, Georgia State, Troy, Middle Tennessee, UAB, Kennesaw State)
Cotton (Jacksonville State, South Alabama, Southern Miss, Louisiana Tech, Louisiana, Missourri State, Arkansas State, UL Monroe)
Notes: The Mountain West and Pacific conferences are controlled by CBS, already are small, and with one exception each are very geographically reasonable. So they will neither need to nor be able to realign. MAC is huge, stable, non-competitive, geographically sensible and very traditional, so I don't see how they'll fit into any of this.
Pacific (Washington State, Oregon State, Boise St., Texas St., Utah St., Fresno St., Colorado St., San Diego St.)
Mountain West (New Mexico, Wyoming, Air Force, N Illinois, N Dakota St., UNLV, San Jose State, Hawaii, UTEP)
So here's the point: A good team in one of these conferences might face one other decent team in their own conference, three other conference leaders, a conference championship game, and a major-conferrence opponent. This gives them six reasonable tests, close to as many as a team in the ACC, Big 12 or Big Ten might face if they don't finish first. (I'd guess teams from these conferences would face decent opposition in five or six of nine in-conference opponents, and one out-of-conference opponents.)
Dear FRiends,
We need your continuing support to keep FR funded. Your donations are our sole source of funding. No sugar daddies, no advertisers, no paid memberships, no commercial sales, no gimmicks, no tax subsidies. No spam, no pop-ups, no ad trackers.
If you enjoy using FR and agree it's a worthwhile endeavor, please consider making a contribution today:
Click here: to donate by Credit Card
Or here: to donate by PayPal
Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794
Thank you very much and God bless you,
Jim
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.