[No.6]

Without even viewing; a combat archer is a specialized role, requiring long training, and tactical placement and protection from… well just about any other unit.

Lots of trade offs. Also swords don’t run out of ammunition.

[Resolute Conservative]

Akin to snipers. They are an important part of the military but not the main force.

[NorthMountain]

Meanwhile, the Roman scutum (large rectangular shield) and the testudo (turtle) formation protected heavy infantry long enough to close with the enemy and hack them to pieces with their short swords.