Islam is not compatible with Western Civilization. The most humane thing to do is to send them back to their muslim country.
This is not complicated,
“Does America have a duty to tolerate that which threatens it?”
NO, no one or thing has a duty to tolerate that which wants to destroy it, expecting otherwise is exactly what creates abused, failed relations, expecting the thing to just accept the abuse. No one or thing has any inherent right to destroy that which is not theirs.
How is this even debatable, imo another example of being educated beyond the intelligence needed to understand the subject.