His Twlight Zone where he played Death, one of his first is amazing. The Sting, The Natural, Legal Eagles, and All is Lost. All solid.
I’m not saying he was one of the top ever or anything, but he was pretty great in a few.
I remember Redford from a 1961 episode of Alfred Hitchcock presents . This : https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0508340/
Disliked “Legal Eagles” and in “The Sting” Newman carried him through the movie imo.
Just a personal opinion of his acting. I wish his loved one’s peace and he obvious was a better actor than many.