>I heard there was violence <
Here’s a longer video of the incident. The welder started to resist arrest at around the 13:50 mark. That’s always a mistake. But I can’t blame him because he really didn’t do anything wrong.
The cop decided to manufacture a crime. And so he did.
I would love to be on that jury.
I appreciate you making that ‘longer video’ available to us, but frankly, I did not wish to sit and watch the entire episode, even though this is a captivating story.
I’m just hoping that Cop has had a share of comeuppance for his unprofessional behavior.
bttt
I agree completely with You. I looked into this and there’s a utterly stupid freaking law about it.
https://legalclarity.org/is-it-illegal-to-honk-your-horn-in-new-york/
Statewide Horn Honking Laws
Beyond New York City, the New York State Vehicle and Traffic Law (VTL) also addresses horn usage. VTL § 375 mandates that every motor vehicle must have a horn or signaling device capable of producing a sound loud enough to serve as a danger warning. This state law further specifies that the horn should not be used for any purpose other than a reasonable warning, nor should it be unnecessarily loud or harsh.
While the state law shares the principle of using a horn for warning, it is generally interpreted as less restrictive than New York City’s explicit prohibition on all non-danger warnings. The state regulation still emphasizes that the horn’s purpose is for safety, preventing its use for general communication or impatience.
Permissible Uses of a Car Horn
Despite the restrictions, there are specific situations where using a car horn is legally permissible and even expected. This means the horn should be used to alert others to an immediate threat or to prevent an impending collision.
Examples of legally justified honking include alerting a pedestrian who is about to step into the path of your vehicle without looking. It is also appropriate to sound your horn to warn another driver who is drifting into your lane or appears unaware of your presence, potentially preventing a side-swipe. Additionally, honking when approaching a blind curve on a narrow road can warn oncoming traffic of your presence, reducing the risk of a head-on collision.
Penalties for Unlawful Honking
Violating horn-honking laws in New York City can result in financial penalties. A summons for unnecessary honking under New York City Traffic Rules, Section 4-12(i), carries a fine of $130. However, the New York City Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) Noise Enforcement Camera Program issues violations for excessive vehicle noise, which can include honking, with fines starting at $800 for a first offense, $1,700 for a second offense within 12 months, and $2,500 for a third or subsequent offense within 12 months.
The city’s Noise Enforcement Camera Program, managed by the DEP, is an active enforcement initiative that began issuing violations in 2022. Local Law 7 of 2024 further mandates this program, requiring the DEP to install no fewer than 5 noise cameras in each borough by September 2025