Replies

"Messianic Judaism is the term given to the belief system of Jewish people who believe and have accepted Yeshua (the Hebrew name for Jesus) of Nazareth as the promised Messiah of the Hebrew Scriptures. These Jewish people do not stop being Jewish, but they continue to remain strong in their Jewish identity, lifestyle and culture, while following Yeshua as He is revealed in the Brit Chadashah, the New Covenant. Many Messianic Jews refer to themselves as “completed Jews,” since they believe that their faith in the God of Israel has been “completed” or fulfilled in Yeshua.
In reality, Messianic Judaism began 2,000 years ago. Yeshua Himself was an observant Jew, most of the apostles and writers of the New Covenant were Jewish, and the vast majority of the early believers in Yeshua were also Jewish (see Acts chapter 2). Traditional rabbinical Judaism today does not believe that Yeshua is the Jewish Messiah. Observant Jews are still waiting faithfully in accordance with the Rambam’s (Rabbi Moses Maimonides, 1134-1204) “Thirteen Principles of Jewish Faith,” which states in Principle 12, “I believe with perfect faith in the coming of the Messiah. However long it takes, I will await His coming every day.” Most secular Jews do not believe in the physical coming of a personal Messiah, but some still look forward to a general Messianic concept or Messianic Age.
Today, it is estimated that there are over 350,000 Messianic Jews in the world, and the numbers are growing all the time. Messianic synagogues have also become very popular, and recent estimates number more than 200 congregations in the U.S. There are also many Messianic congregations in Israel and around the world.
Messianic Jews continue to celebrate the Jewish festivals and feast days as prescribed in the Hebrew Scriptures (i.e., Feast of Weeks, Feast of Tabernacles, etc.), but their observances are meant to demonstrate how Yeshua has already fulfilled these Holy Days. Most Messianic Jews, if they celebrate Easter, remove the pagan influences and celebrate only what is given in the Bible—viz., the Passover. Jews who now follow Yeshua the Messiah understand that everything given in the Old Covenant was a “mere shadow” of the better things to come in the New." (Source: GotQuestions.org)

The more important question is "Can I be Catholic -- and be a Christian believing and following all of their stated beliefs and practices ?"

ESPECIALLY - if you simultaneously believe what the Bible says about salvation, grace, Jesus, the one true Church, Peter, works of the flesh, Mary, ... and a host of other subjects...

I won't reply to whatever you say in reply. Do your own study.

“The more important question is “Can I be Catholic — and be a Christian believing and following all of their stated beliefs and practices ?”

I’m not sure I understand your question to the other poster.

Are you asking if a person be Catholic (and follow their beliefs/practices) and be a Christian?

Or, are you asking “Can I be a Messianic Jew and be a Christian?”

Or, are you asking “Can I be a Messianic Jew and be a Catholic?”

Sorry to bother you (and interrupt) but there is a non-specific pronoun in the question that I can’t follow.