https://www.reddit.com/r/UkraineRussiaReport/comments/17wrd3z/ua_pov_analyzing_big_serge_who_is_of_course_ru/
Sergei’s writings seem to be well studied and accurate assessments of what is transpiring in the Battlefield. However, for the last 3 years we’ve heard nothing but falsehoods from Zeepers (Putin’s dying, Russians fighting only with entrenching tools, Russia Starving, etc.)
Big Serge is the best commentator on the war. I saw that reddit piece a good while ago, and it just nitpicks out of Serge’s copious writings to show that he is not infallible. But on the whole he’s very, very good. Show me another commentator who has written a similar amount whom we can’t come up with 10X as many flaws.
Besides, the critic here comes across as badly wrong in some of his claims himself. He claims HIMARS is a big deal, when that is ridiculous in hindsight. And he criticizes Serge for failing to predict the Russian withdrawal from Kherson; but that sort of thing requires mind-reading the Russian general staff in a prophetic way. And what shall we say of the critics’ claim that Ukraine ever had artillery parity? The critic is a hallucinating himself.