Interesting that you never mention all of the relapses that you witnessed.
That was because I was never aware of any relapses! I can’t say that there weren’t any, but I never heard of anyone being removed before they completed the two year program.
Have you ever been involved with any program, including AA? What makes you so skeptical?
I suppose our program might have been unique. I certainly visited one group which certainly was dirty. But, on the other hand, I can vouch for our ptogram and assure you that it did not have the shortcomings to which you allude.