[Publius]

What about illegals not of Indian ancestry? Chinese, for example?

You can make a stronger argument using the Three Fifths Rule.

[Unrepentant VN Vet]

.

[Farcesensitive]

They are all foreign invaders who are not subject to our jurisdiction.
Slaves were subject to our jurisdiction.

Foreigners not subject to our jurisdiction do not even count for 3/5ths.