not everyone was happy about Russell T Davies’ inclusive casting.
The casting wasn't the problem, or rather wasn't the major problem. The writing reminded me of what was done to Indiana Jones and Luke Skywalker by ideological stooges: turn a former hero into a contemptible chump and displace him with something more acceptable to The Message. And by all reports Tennant was delighted to do it.
The 2nd and 3rd Specials were good. The first was a dumpster fire.