.
The only other contender is that mint-choco chip cone my Uncle
bought me on the Wildwood, New Jersey boardwalk when I was 5.
(Yes, I still remember that from 54 years ago - so it must have been good.)
Great memory!
My favorite was the Planters Peanut boardwalk store.
I remember pistachio ice-cream we used to go out for as a family (We could get any flavor- i chose pistachio)- also nearly 54 years ago- my other favorite was wild cherry