ummm, the whole point of the movie is the celebration of perfect love. Had he lived - and both of them are on the ship looking for the Titanic...talking: Well, she says, “he was so hansom and charming. I never would have guessed he’s spend 50 years forgetting to put the toilet seat down. And Jack responds with, “And you with all that beauty and a headache most nights...” The movie needs to end the way it did...