Unfortunately we play into their hands arguing this crap on its merits, since their arguments are baseless. What we need to do as go after their MOTIVES.
In this case, simply ask “So, what scares you so much about Voter ID when even 60% (or more) of Democrat voters want it? Do you know about things going on that others do not?”
“Unfortunately we play into their hands arguing this crap on its merits...”
That’s true of just about everything.
Everything they say is baseless and illogical.
It’s a victory for them to even engage in argument on absurd and irrational things.
And, “Why do you think blacks are so stupid and incompetent that they can’t get an ID? Isn’t that racist?”