I’m a drummer, and comparing Gadd to Peart is sort of an apples/oranges debate.
Neal was an amazing player and had his own unique style. So do Garibaldi, Vinnie, Belson, Rich, Tony Williams, Bonham, Moon, Cobham and so many others...
Absolutely, when we start to perfect our craft we flow into our own unique style as individuals. That is when the energy is tapped and we let it take over and direct us with the improvisation.
There comes a time when you become so proficient that you can do anything anyone else out there can do, including Neil Peart. This is when you come into and discover your own...
I bought a Ringo set that was sold to me by the second owner Billy Cobham. I still have the original cymbals that Ringo used on their first US TV appearance, the Ed Sullivan show. (documented) :)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JC0MEF6d1eU
Best drummer is subjective. He’s my absolute favorite and inspiring drummer and his songwriting and poetry is incredible. First time i think I weeped a bit due to a celebrity death...he inspired me as a kid and drummer, musician. Time Stand Still!!!