That makes me think of the “The Thirty-Fathom Grave” episode which I watched not long ago and found it to be that bit spooky (it featured Simon Oakland and Mike Kellin and it was about Kellin being the survivor of a submarine that was wrecked in World War II and he ends up being on a Navy ship that years after the war goes to the location where the submarine sank during the war).
Definitely a ‘Final Destination’ episode.