As Mrs. Clinton began her 2016 campaign for the presidency, Hugh Rodham and Roger Clinton had faded from public view, but Tony Rodham emerged as a controversial figure.
A government investigation in March found that GreenTech, which sought green cards for its Chinese investors through an American government program, had received special treatment in the handling of its visa applications.
The report described instances when Mr. McAuliffe and Mr. Rodham contacted an official from the Department of Homeland Security to complain about the pace of the visa process.
Mr. Rodham described his dire financial situation during the court proceedings in 2012. As a result of a series of failed business deals including some in oil and gas, water, housing, tutoring and pharmaceuticals he said he had not made a mortgage payment in 10 months and was fighting home foreclosure.
The Clintons, he said, had been generous, even paying for his sons schooling, but they were not going to give him more money. Hillary and Bill are done, he said. I mean, look at what theyve done for me. Theyve given me money all the time.
Mr. Clintons willingness to assist in getting him work with Mr. McAuliffe was helpful, Mr. Rodham said, but at $6,000 a month, it was not enough. Its kind of like the job he got me a long time ago when I worked in the prison, he said.